Other than knowing for certain that I'd love to spend a week at an all-inclusive Sandals Resort, I know that I definitely want to be at a pretty beach. I can't pick which beach though. Some of the locations I'm considering are below.
Mexico:
Cancun or Riviera Maya (relatively similar in location).
Pros
Pretty beach. All-inclusives available. 4-5 star resorts fit within our budget. I know exactly where my passport is.
Cons
I don't speak Spanish. Sheldon can't find his passport. I refuse to change planes in Mexico City; it must be a direct flight. I have to book the vacation early to ensure flight schedule and good prices.
Link to possible hotel
Pictures


Carribbean:
There's really not a point in listing all of this because we can't afford it. But I'll do it anyway.
Pros
Love the beaches! Well...from the pictures I've seen. I don't really know anything else about it.
Cons
The cost.
Links to possible hotels
Pictures
Alabama:
Pros
Beautiful beaches. Family is close by. I don't have to book anything early. We can drive. The hotels are affordable. It's in the U.S. - no passport required.
Cons
Family is close by (*I realize I have this in both categories). The hotels aren't all-inclusive and they're only 1 or 2 star-rated. However, I did find a really cute bed and breakfast, which is extremely affordable.
Link to possible B&B
Pictures


*Family ranks as a pro and a con on vacation. Pro: I don't live near them so it would be nice to be able to visit everyone while I have a week off in June. Con: I don't want to be overrun with family during my "baby-makin'" vacation. :) So you can see, they don't cancel each other out even though family is listed on both the pros and the cons list. I think by the time vacation gets here, I won't care where I'm going as long as I'm with my husband and we're going somewhere with pretty water. But you can still comment on what your decision would be. :)